Reaching new heights: Moontown brews up six months of success

It seems like a story told time and again — a homebrewer transforms their hobby into a full-scale enterprise. Except this venture was more than a dream or a leap of faith. The folks at Moontown Brewing Company knew what they were getting into, and they hand-picked the people and place that would make it happen.

Moontown co-owners Bobby Mattingly, left, and Cody Peczkowski, right, enjoy a brew in Oktoberfest “das boot” mugs. (Photo by Sara Baldwin Schatz)

Moontown, Whitestown’s first brewery, opened in March and recently celebrated a successful first six months in business. The brewery will host its inaugural Oktoberfest celebration Oct. 6.

“I can’t even imagine it going any better than it has gone. We are already getting pressured to can beer, distribute and expand,” Moontown co-founder Bobby Mattingly said.

A culmination of several individual aspirations led to the March 2018 launch of Moontown. Zionsville resident and commercial builder, Pete Mattingly, had a passion for homebrew since the early 2000s. His son Patrick inherited his old equipment in 2006 and began brewing with his Purdue University colleague, Cody Peczkowski.

In 2007, Pete’s King of Troy lager was given a perfect score by the judges at the Indiana State Fair Homebrew Competition.

“At that point he knew he was making some good beer,” said Bobby, Pete’s youngest son.

A salvaged site

The Mattingly family began brewing together in 2015 as Moontown, and planned to eventually open a full-scale brewery. They began looking at potential sites in Zionsville, Lebanon and Whitestown. Later that year, Moontown won first place in the inaugural Whitestown Beer Fest. Town Manager Dax Norton approached the family after the festival, suggesting they turn a historic building on Bowers Street into a brewery.

345 South Bowers St., built in the early 1900s, 345 South Bowers St. was home to Whitestown High School until 1963. It is part of Whitestown’s “Legacy Core”, the original downtown area. By the time it was offered to Moontown, it had deteriorated significantly.

“It was structurally sound, but needed a lot of work,” Bobby said.

The town sold the building to Moontown for $1, agreeing to repair a dilapidated roof.

Pete’s company, MattCon General Contractors, began renovations in May 2017. Patrick is project manager for the company and oversaw the Moontown construction. More than a year of restoration included electrical, plumbing and HVAC updates, and the construction of interior walls.

Throughout the renovation process historic elements were preserved, with details such as repainting the basketball court markings and salvaging bleacher seats as wood trim.

Patrons can order a flight of beers to sample Moontown’s offerings. Pictured from left to right are; Hef- Czowski, a traditional German Hefeweisen brewed from malted wheat; Bam Bam, a fruity pale-meets- wheat beer; Into the Void, a robust porter; and Choco-Dece, a double-chocolate milk stout.

The perfect crew

While the brewery was becoming a reality, Bobby and Patrick recruited Peczkowski, who had left a corporate job to pursue his interest in brewing craft beer for Gordon Biersch, a German-style brewery chain. Moontown made Peczkowski an official offer mid-2017. That same week, Gordon Biersch announced it was closing Peczkowski’s location.

“The timing all lined up too perfectly,” Peczkowski said.

Peczkowski, now head brewer, oversees a 15-barrel brewing system. The bar offers eight rotating taps as well as a full liquor and wine list. Private events and concerts are held in the attached 1915 room.

Moontown Chef Dave Slama recommends pairing the classics for the ultimate Moontown experience. Pictured are the All-American Burger, featuring a triple beef patty and a side of fries, with King of Troy, a crisp lager made with German malt.

Sourcing ingredients locally is important to Moontown. In a tall silo outside the building, malt from Sugar Creek Malt in neighboring Lebanon is stored. It is not only used in brewing, but also in flatbreads and breading, after being ground to a flour.

Bobby recruited fellow Zionsville Community High School graduate Dave Slama away from his job at Bluebeard to become Moontown’s head chef. Slama has cultivated relationships with local farmers and artisans including Smoking Goose Meatery and Tinker Coffee of Indianapolis, and Lebanon’s Saint Adrian Meat & Sausage.

Also on the team are Samson Corrado, who attended both ZCHS and IU with Bobby, and Georgia Rheinhardt, who Bobby met at IU. With her experience managing events at Traders Point Creamery, Rheinhardt was the perfect person to take on the role of marketing and events manager.

“The quality of the people involved has made all the difference,” Peczkowski said. “This was not a whim and a hope.”

Oktoberfest will take over Moontown Brewing Company’s entire facility on Oct 6 from noon to 11 p.m. The day will consist of beer tappings, two live concerts, a German costume contest and more. To purchase a ticket visit

Cycle of the Moontown

2003 – Pete Mattingly began home brewing. The first beer he brewed was King of Troy, a lager named after his grandfather’s hometown of Troy, Ind.

2006 – Patrick Mattingly and Peczkowski began home brewing while living in Lafayette and attending Purdue University. The first beer they brewed together was a porter called Into the Void, using hand-me-down equipment from Pete.

2007 – Pete’s King of Troy lager received a high rating at the the Indiana State Fair Homebrew Competition.

2013 – Peczkowski began working at Gordon Biersch Brewery Restaurant.

2014 – Bobby Mattingly and Samson Corrado moved to Miami, Fl. together after college, taking jobs at National Construction Workforce.

Jan. 2015 – Samson and Bobby moved back to Indiana from Miami. Bobby asked his father, Pete, to teach him more about home brewing. Moontown became a brewery-in-planning.

Sept. 2015 – Moontown Brewing Company wins first place at the Whitestown Brewfest. After the festival, Whitestown Town Manager, Dax Norton, offered Moontown a permanent home in Whitestown.

April 2016 -Peczkowski moved to Kansas City to help open a Gordon Biersch location. Soon after, Bobby and Pat visited Peczkowski to recruit him for Moontown.

May 2017 – Construction began on the Bowers Street historic site after finalizing a re-development deal with Whitestown.

Bobby Mattingly unloads the brewing equipment on a hot summer day in 2017. “We worked through the night and brought everything in one piece at a time,” Bobby said.

Bobby Mattingly unloads the brewing equipment on a hot summer day in 2017. “We worked through the night and brought everything in one piece at a time,” Bobby said.

Sept. 2017 -Peczkowski moved to Indianapolis to become a partner at Moontown. The brewing equipment arrived soon after.

Dec. 2017 – The Moontown crew brewed King of Troy for the first time on the new equipment. It was the first legally brewed beer in Boone County since the repeal of Prohibition

Jan. 2018 – Moontown had a soft opening.

March 2018 – Moontown officially opened for business.

Current Morning Briefing Logo

Stay CURRENT with our daily newsletter (M-F) and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox for free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Current Publishing, 30 S. Range Line Road, Carmel, IN, 46032, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact