Filling a hole: Landings’ housing, commercial development receives backlash


The Westfield Advisory Plan Commission began its Aug. 5 meeting at City Hall with a statement from Westfield Fire Marshal Garry Harling regarding the council chambers’ capacity — which, at the time, was overflowing.

The statement, read by Advisory Plan Commission President Randy Graham, said all attendees must be seated, that entrances and aisles not be blocked and that the nearly 100 people waiting outside could not enter the building unless others inside left.

The room holds 110, and nearly double that many people attended to voice their opinion on a proposed development – The Landings at Village Farms – at the northeastern corner of 146th Street and Oak Ridge Road.

The room holds 110, but nearly double that many people attended to voice their opinion on a proposed development – The Landings at Village Farms – at the northeastern corner of 146th Street and Oak Ridge Road.

Petitioners Pulte Homes and Mark Zukerman are requesting a change of zoning to allow for more dense housing and commercial buildings on a 58-acre space. The project, if approved, would fill the void in an area that consists several neighborhoods, including Village Farms, Hills and Dales West, Rolling Meadows, Beacon Point, Shadow Lakes, Hunters Creek Village and Westfield Farms, among others, in addition to Our Lady of Mount Carmel school.

If the petition is approved by the Westfield City Council, the land would change from single-family, low-density zoning to single-family, high-density and local business district zoning, something many residents don’t want, which they made clear during the meeting’s public hearing.

The 94 proposed homes would be built on 41 acres, along with two detention ponds and other amenities. The commercial portion would comprise 11 acres facing 146th Street on the southern portion of the 58-acre area. Just north of the commercial area is an approximately 6-acre utility easement.

A character exhibit of the proposed two-story homes.

“The LB, or local business, zoning excludes uses for things like fast-food restaurants, gas stations or other larger general business uses,” said Jon Dobosiewicz, an attorney with Nelson & Frankenberger representing petitioners Pulte Homes and Zukerman. “This (zoning) allows for businesses (like) a drugstore, day care, medical office, coffee shop, or other personal service uses, more in line with areas that serve residents surrounding the site.”

Dobosiewicz said the purchase price for the ranch-style and two-story homes would range from $325,000 to $360,000, with a minimum of 1,600 square feet and 2,300 square feet, respectively.

Dobosiewicz said the price point is lower than the homes in Village Farms.

“As a point of reference, we looked and determined through a broker that homes in Village Farms over the last two years, the average sale price for homes within Village Farms was $367,000,” he said. “That’s based upon data received from sales over the past two years.”

A character exhibit of the proposed ranch- style homes.

Regarding amenities, The Landings proposal includes several that Dobosiewicz said are in line with the city’s unified development ordinance and include a pocket park, a large park with open space, walking trails, a canoe/kayak launch and trail connectivity.

Before the start of the public hearing, a stack of comment cards with names of those wishing to voice opionions on the project numbered more than 50.

Erma Clark, a Village Farms resident, said she is concerned about pedestrian and traffic safety, but also wants to see the area remain undeveloped.

“I am right across the street from this development,” she said. “I have a daughter and son-in-law and two granddaughters who live in Village Farms. I am against any development in that area for several reasons – water displacement, increased traffic, increased crime, not to mention a utility easement that’s in an environmentally sensitive area. Not every square foot of farmland should be developed.”

Many residents who spoke said they understood the open land would someday be developed but that they have concerns about the need for commercial buildings in the neighborhood.

A concept plan for The Landings at Village Farms shows 94 proposed homes, an existing lake, three detention ponds, 11 acres of commercial development, parks and trails. (Submitted image)

Doug Evans, a 20-year Village Farms resident, said he is against rezoning.

“We have so much vacant real estate within a mile,” Evans said. “It’s empty building after empty building.”

Resident Troy Yoder said he took it upon himself to look into commercial spaces already open in the area.

“I drove the route from over by LA Fitness to Clay Terrace up to Target over to Walmart, and there are 17 open commercial sites in less than a mile from this location,” Yoder said. “Online retailing is not decreasing as I’ve heard from every source on the planet, so I’m not sure why in the world we would do this. It makes zero sense.”

Matt Sprague, a Westfield Farms resident, whose home abuts the proposed development on the southeast side, also opposes rezoning.

“There’s one home that has this parking lot right behind the house. That’s my house. Do any of you want a parking lot in your backyard?” Sprague said. “I have five or six pharmacies within a mile of my house. Why do I need another pharmacy?”

Other residents said the density simply doesn’t match the homes surrounding the area. Taking into account space for amenities, detention ponds and open space, the plan would put two or three homes on each acre of residential development.

Because the item was presented for the public hearing, the APC did not vote to send a recommendation to the city council, which will give final approval on the rezoning request. The APC will vote on a recommendation at its next meeting at 7 p.m. Aug. 19 at City Hall, 130 Penn St. For more, or to see an agenda, visit

Current Morning Briefing Logo

Stay CURRENT with our daily newsletter (M-F) and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox for free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Current Publishing, 30 S. Range Line Road, Carmel, IN, 46032, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact