Two women shepherd Carmel church’s flock


By Amanda Foust



Carmel’s Orchard Park Presbyterian Church is currently being led by two female pastors — a first for Carmel churches.

Pastor Shelly Wood and Interim Associate Pastor Kim Olson are the two women in leadership.

Olson was brought to Orchard Park to temporarily fill a position due to a church transitional period, but she has been in ministry for twenty-one years. During those first years in seminary, she discovered quickly that many of the women were in seminary for their second career. She was proudly a part of the first wave of women who had ministry as their first career.



What made her endeavor into ministry difficult was the lack of mentors and the concern of family support.

“While I was in graduate school, I met my first female pastor,” Olson said. “I thought ‘Wow! These are women, and they are going to be pastors!’”

Olson felt concern over what her family would say because not all denominations allow female pastors.

“In high school I had an inkling I was going to be a pastor, but I asked my mom if that was OK,” she said. “She said she didn’t know any, so I thought it wasn’t.”

Wood describes her thirteen year journey in ministry in a similar way to Olson. Growing up, Wood remembers all her ministers being men.

She said, “It took me a long time to see myself in a role other than a gender-bias role teaching Sunday school or in the kitchen.”

As a previous pastor of a mid-size church in Iowa, Wood soon felt the need to begin a new chapter.

“My children were at junior high age, and I didn’t want to move them during high school,” she said. “I wanted to get that done before the journey of adolescence. I started to look for a new call two years ago.”

She was looking for a congregation like Orchard Park to be the perfect fit. And Wood and Olson also claim to be the perfect fit. They both agree they are a strong team.

“Kim is really good at saying ‘Let’s reexamine,’ and I’m really good at saying, ‘What’s at the finish line?’” Wood said.

Olson agrees that they balance each other in more ways than one.

In addition to balance, having family at home and a full time job is a balancing act.

“Having family participate in the life of the congregation is important,” Olson said. “Many times balance is a struggle, and sometimes it’s not pretty where you don’t feel you are doing well at work or at home.”

Wood agreed and has learned the trick to a balancing act is understanding it is truly just an act. She believes in stripping away the guilt and offering yourself grace while finding the balance.

Both Olson and Wood understand that although women in church leadership is not yet common, love for God and the Presbyterian Church is what’s most important. Olson knows they have both been called to these positions and share a passion for people, building up discipleship, and community outreach.

Wood said, “We both love the Presbyterian Church. We both have the same desire for the Presbyterian Church to be alive and well in the 21st century.”

Current Morning Briefing Logo

Stay CURRENT with our daily newsletter (M-F) and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox for free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Current Publishing, 30 S. Range Line Road, Carmel, IN, 46032, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact