Hamilton County Democratic Party chair filled vacant Fishers City Council seat without a quorum


In a statement released May 7, the Hamilton County Democratic Party acknowledged that Party Chair Dayna Colbert selected Crystal Neumann to fill a vacant Fishers City Council seat during an April 25 caucus because a quorum wasn’t present.


Consequently, a vote wasn’t taken to choose between Neumann and fellow candidate Chauna Leigh Holder. As permitted by Indiana statute, Colbert selected Neumann to represent the North Central District. The seat became vacant when Samantha Long resigned because her husband took a job in Nevada.

After the caucus, the party stated that the final vote tally was kept confidential, even though a vote wasn’t actually taken.

“As part of our continued efforts to improve transparency within our party and community, I would like to clarify the details of the appointment of Councilor Crystal Neumann and respond to a report that was published suggesting that the Hamilton County Democratic Party misrepresented the outcome of the caucus,” Colbert stated in a subsequent media release. “After reviewing the statement issued after the caucus, I have concluded that the language used in the statement did not meet the expectations of transparency I have set forth in leading our party forward.”

According to Colbert, after verifying which members were eligible to participate in the caucus with Hamilton County Election Administrator Beth Sheller, the Hamilton County Democrats reached out to the eligible committee members through certified mail, by phone and by email. But on the day of the caucus, not enough committee persons arrived to form a quorum, so Colbert selected Neumann.

“We reached out to the (precinct committeemen) we had confirmation (from) and we should have had a quorum,” Colbert said. “Unfortunately, a personal matter came right before for one of the (precinct committeemen), so we were not able to reach the quorum.”

A quorum is a majority of eligible voters, and the Hamilton County Democratic Party fell one person short.

“I was disappointed that the quorum didn’t wind up happening, but I know that life happens,” Neumann said. “I had a speech ready and had questions to answer and I was just ready to share my thoughts and my perspectives with everyone.”

Neumann still gave her speech and took questions from the precinct committeemen present. Then, instead of waiting for a caucus to decide, Colbert selected Neumann to fill the seat.

“(Colbert) was behind closed doors and I was talking to Chauna about our hopes for the City of Fishers, just a very casual conversation,” Neumann said. “When Dayna came out and made the announcement, I was still pretty shocked because I thought they were going to choose Chauna because she was another great candidate. But I was still very excited about the announcement and the chance to serve Fishers.”

According to Indiana Code, “If a quorum required under the rules of a meeting held under this chapter is not present, the county chairman or an individual designated by the county chairman shall fill the vacancy that exists in the local office.”

I regret that our previous statement did not live up to our own values and will continue to work to improve our communication as we move forward,” Colbert stated in the follow-up media release.  “I, together with the Hamilton County Democratic Party, welcome and expect to be held accountable by residents.”


Current Morning Briefing Logo

Stay CURRENT with our daily newsletter (M-F) and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox for free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: . You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact